Devin McDermott
Work with me
Get the daily email Work with me
A man sweeping a metal detector across an empty beach at golden hour, a long winding trail of footprints behind him

Why a Guy Can Search for Forty Minutes and Still Come Up Empty

By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach

Blog4 minute read

A guy can scroll for forty minutes looking for the right one and still feel empty after. A 1950s pigeon experiment shows what's actually hooking him.

In the 1950s, a psychologist named B.F. Skinner spent a lot of time with pigeons.

He'd put a pigeon in a box with a small disc on the wall. Peck the disc, and sometimes food dropped out.

Some pigeons got food every time they pecked. Others got it at random. Sometimes on the first peck, sometimes on the fiftieth. No way to predict it.

You'd think the pigeons that got fed every time would work the hardest.

But the random ones pecked faster. And when Skinner shut the food off completely, the random ones kept pecking long after the others gave up.

The not knowing is what hooked them. Maybe this peck. Maybe the next one.

The Same Trick Runs a Casino

Slot machines run on the same idea.

A slot machine doesn't pay out on a schedule anybody can predict. Most pulls pay nothing. Every so often, one pays something. And because nobody knows which pull it'll be, people keep pulling long after the money stopped making sense.

Skinner and his colleague Charles Ferster spent years mapping this out. In 1957 they published a book full of the records from these experiments. The pattern held up over and over: when the reward is unpredictable, the behavior gets faster and harder to stop.

What the Search Is Really Doing

And a guy's search works the same way.

He thinks what he's after is the video. But watch what actually happens. He opens his phone and starts scrolling. This one's close. Not quite. Maybe the next one. Twenty minutes go by, then forty, and he's still looking for the perfect one.

So the search is the slot machine, and he's the pigeon.

That's why it so often ends feeling empty. He finally stops, and it's like he never found what he was looking for. Because what kept him there was the maybe.

Then the Pigeons Started Dancing

Skinner ran another experiment that's even stranger.

In 1948, he gave eight hungry pigeons food every fifteen seconds, no matter what they did. The food had nothing to do with their behavior.

But the pigeons didn't know that. Six of the eight started doing odd little rituals. One turned in circles. Another kept jerking its head into a corner of the box. Whatever a pigeon happened to be doing when the food showed up, it did more of, as if the dance was what made the food come.

A guy's brain does something similar with everything around the search. The late hour. The same app. The "I'm just checking something" that starts it. None of those are the reward. But they were always there right before it, so after enough times, they start to feel like part of it.

That's why the pull can kick in before he's even decided anything. His brain already knows the dance.

The Brain Works Hardest on a Maybe

But the biggest hook is still the maybe, and researchers have watched it work in the brain.

In 2003, a team at the University of Cambridge led by Wolfram Schultz recorded the dopamine cells of monkeys while the monkeys waited on rewards. Some cues meant a reward was certain. Some meant it would never come. And some meant maybe.

The dopamine cells did something interesting with the maybes. While the monkeys waited, activity built up the most when the odds were close to fifty-fifty. When the outcome was most uncertain, those cells were working hardest.

So the moment a guy is most hooked comes during the scrolling, while it might still be the next one, or the one after that.

Why Willpower Keeps Losing Here

It's also why willpower struggles so much here. Willpower argues with the one on the screen. But the pull comes from the next one, the one he hasn't seen yet.

A guy can tell himself "just this one" and mean it. But the maybe is still running underneath, and the maybe always points at the next one.

That's a big part of why willpower alone keeps failing for so many guys, and why the urge seems to argue back no matter how good his reasons are.

So when a guy can't stop once he's started, he's doing exactly what Skinner's random pigeons did. And like them, he keeps pecking long after it's stopped paying out.

Once you can see the maybe for what it is, it loses a lot of its grip.

Questions Guys Ask Me About This

Why can't I stop once I start searching?

Because the searching is the hook. Every scroll might turn up something better than the last one, and a brain treats a reward it can't predict as one worth chasing. Skinner's pigeons showed it in the 1950s: the ones fed at random pecked faster and kept going longer than the ones fed every time.

Why do I feel empty after?

Because for a guy stuck in that loop, the hunt was the part that had him, and the hunt ends the moment he stops. What he finds at the end rarely matches the pull of looking for it. So he walks away with less than the search promised him, and still half looking for the next one.

Why does the urge start before I've even decided to look?

Because a guy's brain ties the search to everything that usually comes right before it: the late hour, the same app, the "I'm just checking something" moment. Skinner saw the same thing in 1948, when pigeons fed on a timer kept repeating whatever they'd been doing when the food showed up. So by the time he's deciding, the pull has already started.

Does this mean something is wrong with me?

No. A pigeon fed at random keeps pecking, and nobody calls the pigeon weak. Your brain is responding to unpredictable rewards the way any brain does. Seeing that is often the first time a guy stops blaming his character for something his wiring was built to do.


Get the next one tomorrow.

These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.

Devin McDermott

Devin McDermott

I was hooked on porn for 13 years. I've been free for nearly six, and I've coached 170+ men through it since. No shame, no lectures.

My storyWork with me

Keep reading

Every post

Sources

  • Ferster, C. B., & Skinner, B. F. (1957). Schedules of Reinforcement. Appleton-Century-Crofts. Variable schedules produce high, steady response rates, and intermittent rewards keep behavior going long after the rewards stop. Summary: Simply Psychology.
  • Slot machines and unpredictable rewards: Simply Psychology.
  • Skinner, B. F. (1948). 'Superstition' in the pigeon. Journal of Experimental Psychology, 38(2), 168-172.
  • Fiorillo, C. D., Tobler, P. N., & Schultz, W. (2003). Discrete coding of reward probability and uncertainty by dopamine neurons. Science, 299, 1898-1902. PDF.