It Didn't Even Work in My Dreams: Why PIED Takes More Than a Few Weeks
By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach
A few weeks off porn and it still isn't working. Why porn-induced ED takes longer than that, and how the worry about it keeps it going.
"Kindly help."
That's how a reader signed off a question he sent me a while back, and I think a lot of guys have the same one.
He's 31, active, and into sports.
He'd been watching porn and "taking care of things himself" for about 13 years.
Then earlier that month, he'd stopped...
But he was still having a hard time getting and keeping it up.
I know that struggle too.
At 21 I once had a beautiful girl in my bed, and I couldn't keep it up no matter what I tried.
I knew something was wrong, but I didn't know what.
For years I had nightmares about it too, where even in my dreams I couldn't perform.
So I want to answer this reader here.
A Few Weeks Against 13 Years
Thing is, he'd spent about 13 years training his body to respond to a screen.
Less than a month off is a real start, but it's just a couple weeks up against 13 years.
(And if he hasn't had it checked by a doctor, that's worth doing to rule out anything physical. Tons of guys I talk to already have, everything came back fine, and they basically get told "it's all in your head.")
The Fear It Left Behind
But there's a second part to this.
The pressure.
Once a guy's worried about it he starts spiraling.
Every time things get intimate, part of his mind starts wondering. Is it working? Is it going to work this time?
And in my experience, that is one of the surest ways to make it not work.
So on top of the porn, there's now the fear it left behind.
What Helped Me
Something that really helped me was being honest with the woman in my life about what was going on, that I was in a process of healing my dopamine reward center and it affects that response but that it IS healing and getting better over time. Then just working on relaxing and being present which, incidentally, often allowed the machinery to start working better than worrying ever could.
She was incredibly patient with me, and she told me it helped her too because it meant she knew it wasn't her fault.
That bedroom problem healed for me completely after a couple months clean.
That's roughly the timeline I've seen for most of the men I've worked with too.
Before Deciding You're Broken
So if you're a few weeks in and it still isn't working, I'd look at two things before deciding you're broken.
How long the habit had to build and how long you've been clean, because it takes time to reverse.
And how much of your attention is being spent on worrying about it.
All of that can heal. It has for me and many others.
Why Checking on It Makes It Worse
That second part has a name.
In 1970 the sex researchers William Masters and Virginia Johnson called it spectatoring. It's when part of a guy is watching himself instead of being with her. He's grading how it's going while it's still going.
And every bit of attention he spends watching and grading is attention that isn't on her, or on what he's feeling. Researchers who've studied spectatoring since describe that self-watching as a distraction tied to sexual problems.
So the worry ends up feeding the problem. A guy has one night where it doesn't work. The next time he watches more closely, and the watching makes it more likely to go the same way again.
It also says something about the guy it's happening to. A guy who didn't care how it went for her wouldn't be watching so closely.
A 2020 review called sexual performance anxiety one of the most common sexual complaints people have. A lot of guys carry this one quietly and figure they're the only one.
Why It Takes Time to Come Back
For 13 years porn gave that reader's brain a kind of stimulation a real partner doesn't. Endless novelty, and something more extreme any time the last thing got old.
A team that included Navy doctors at Naval Medical Center San Diego wrote about this in a 2016 review. They put it forward as a hypothesis: a guy's arousal can get conditioned to all that, so being with a real person may not work on him the way the screen did.
When he stops, his body has to get used to responding to a real person again. And that often takes longer than a few weeks.
The same review described young servicemen with ED, and it said stopping porn was sometimes enough to reverse it. One 24-year-old sailor stopped completely, and his ED went away. I wrote more about those servicemen in why a guy in the best shape of his life can still have ED.
So a guy who's a few weeks in and still struggling hasn't even reached the couple months it took me.
Questions Guys Ask Me About This
How long does it take to recover from porn-induced ED?
For me it was a couple months clean, and that's roughly the timeline I've seen with a lot of the men I've worked with. A guy who watched for a long time usually needs longer than a guy who didn't. And worrying about it the whole way can slow it down. I go into what the studies show about why it works with porn but not with her.
Why is it still not working after I quit porn?
Once a doctor has ruled out anything physical, I'd look at two things, and often it's both. The habit had years to train a guy's body to respond to a screen, and a few weeks off may not be long enough to undo that. Or the fear of it not working has become its own problem, and he's watching himself so closely that he's not really with her.
Is porn-induced ED all in my head?
Plenty of guys I talk to get told exactly that once their tests come back normal, and it can feel like being told the problem is imaginary. A response trained over years and a fear that keeps checking on it are both real, and both can heal. It's still worth having a doctor rule out anything physical first.
Should I tell my girlfriend or wife about PIED?
Being honest with the woman in my life really helped me. She was patient, and she told me it helped her too because she knew it wasn't her fault. When a guy says nothing, she's left guessing, and she can end up thinking it's her. One of my clients went months without sex because he was scared it wouldn't work, and by then the fear was running the marriage. After he quit he wrote me that he'd "never once felt the fear of losing it."
Can performance anxiety cause ED even after quitting porn?
Yes. In my experience worrying about it is one of the surest ways to make it not work, and that worry doesn't leave just because the porn did. Once a guy has had it fail a few times he starts watching himself in bed, and that pulls his attention off her and off what he feels. The Merck Manual even counts full erections while masturbating among the signs that ED comes from performance anxiety or stress. So if it works when he's alone and not with her, the worry is worth a close look.
Does porn-induced ED go away for good?
It did for me, completely, and it has for many of the men I've worked with. It just doesn't happen on the schedule a guy wants. The habit took years to build, so it needs real time to undo.
Get the next one tomorrow.
These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.
Keep reading
Why a Guy Keeps Going Back to Porn Even After He's Decided to Stop8 min read
Why It Feels Like Nothing's Happening After You Quit Porn7 min read
The Difference Between Staying Off Porn and Being Done With It7 min read
Even Playboy Wrote About Men Quitting Porn. You're Not the Only One.6 min read
Why a Guy Who's Disciplined at Everything Else Still Can't Quit Porn8 min read
What a Porn Habit Takes From a Marriage, Even When Nobody Knows About It7 min read
The Night After a Slip: Why One Bad Night Turns Into a Bad Month5 min read
Why Staying Off Porn Is Only Half of It7 min read
Sources
- "Spectatoring" as Masters and Johnson's term for watching oneself during sex, and that self-focus described as a cognitive distraction associated with sexual dysfunction: Trapnell, P. D., Meston, C. M., & Gorzalka, B. B. (1997). Spectatoring and the relationship between body image and sexual experience: Self-focus or self-valence? The Journal of Sex Research, 34(3), 267-278. PDF. The term comes from Masters, W. H., & Johnson, V. E. (1970). Human Sexual Inadequacy. Little, Brown.
- Sexual performance anxiety as one of the most common sexual complaints: Pyke, R. E. (2020). Sexual performance anxiety. Sexual Medicine Reviews, 8(2), 183-190. PubMed 31447414.
- The Navy review (authors at Naval Medical Center San Diego; the conditioning hypothesis, with limitless novelty and easy escalation to more extreme material; the young servicemen with ED; the 24-year-old whose ED went away after he stopped; and stopping sometimes being enough to reverse the effects): Park, B. Y., Wilson, G., Berger, J., et al. (2016). Is Internet pornography causing sexual dysfunctions? A review with clinical reports. Behavioral Sciences, 6(3), 17. PMC5039517.
- Ruling out physical causes first, and full erections while masturbating as a feature of ED from performance anxiety or stress: Merck Manual Consumer Version, Erectile Dysfunction (ED).
- The client who went months without sex, and his "never once felt the fear of losing it," from his messages shared with his permission: Client stories.