Devin McDermott
Work with me
Get the daily email Work with me
A long line of dominoes on a wooden table in late sun, the first few already falling into the rest

The Night After a Slip: Why One Bad Night Turns Into a Bad Month

By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach

Blog5 minute read

What a guy tells himself the night after a porn relapse can do more damage than the slip itself. Researchers have a name for it, and it explains the binge.

A woman asked me for food...

... and I didn't give her any.

As I walked away that day several months back, I reflected on what I was feeling.

I felt bad, and like my response wasn't truly aligned with my values.

Sure, I wanted to eat that food, but it was leftovers from a place I'd just eaten at and I didn't need it... while she clearly did or she wouldn't have asked.

Is that treating other people the way I'd want to be treated?

No, certainly not.

So I made myself a promise.

Next time someone asks me for food, I'll help if I can.

Then the very next day, I came across a bag someone had left under a table.

It had a woman's wallet in it. And her passport, which is a big deal while traveling internationally.

And I made sure all of it got back to her.

A small redemption that felt good!

I may not have showed up as the best version of myself in that first moment.

But I didn't spend that night deciding I was a terrible person, either.

I just decided what I'd do next time.

So when next time showed up just a day later, I was ready for it.

And it stuck.

Ever since then when someone asks me for food, I help them out whenever I can.

It's happened several times now.

I've bought a few guys sandwiches or chips, and even raided my pantry to give away a bunch of food.

(Because, as they'd say here in Latin America, I'm a pinche gringo, and we apparently all buy too much.)

That one moment I wasn't proud of turned into something I just do now.

What a Guy Tells Himself After a Slip

And I think about that a lot with the guys I work with, because when a guy slips, what he tells himself afterward can do more damage than the slip itself.

"I'm a piece of shit."

"Why am I like this?"

"I'm never going to beat this."

He makes himself feel even more like garbage.

The problem with that is the fastest way he knows to stop feeling like garbage is the exact thing that made him feel that way.

So one bad night turns into a bad weekend, week, or month because "I already blew it anyway."

The shame he was counting on to stop him ends up setting up the next one.

There's a Name for This

Researchers who study relapse noticed this pattern decades ago.

The psychologist Alan Marlatt called it the abstinence violation effect.

A guy sets a rule for himself and breaks it once. Then the self-blame and the feeling that he's already lost control make the next slip more likely.

In a 1987 study of people trying to quit smoking, a team that included Marlatt looked at who slipped once and got back on track, and who slipped and went all the way back.

One thing that set them apart was how they explained the slip to themselves.

The ones who went all the way back tended to blame something permanent about who they were. The kind of explanation that sounds like "I'm just weak." The ones who got back on track were less likely to read it that way.

That study was about cigarettes. But it's the same pattern I see with porn.

Feeling Bad Isn't the Same as Feeling Like Garbage

Psychologists draw a line between guilt and shame.

Guilt is about something he did. "I did a bad thing."

Shame is about who he is. "I'm a bad person."

From the inside, the two can feel almost the same. But they tend to push a guy in different directions.

Guilt keeps his eyes on what he did, so he can own it and make it right. Shame makes him want to hide, and to get away from the feeling as fast as he can. And he already knows the fastest way to do that.

A 2011 study of 177 people seeking help for compulsive porn use found the same split. The people with more shame reported more of the behavior. Guilt went with more motivation to change, and more effort to actually do it.

That's one study, and it can't prove which causes which. But it matches what I've watched happen with the guys I work with.

It's also what happened after that woman asked me for food. What I felt walking away was guilt. It was about one thing I'd done, so it gave me something to fix. And it turned into a promise that got its chance a day later.

What the Guys Who Get Out Do Differently

From what I've observed across the 170+ men I've coached out of their addictions, the guys who get out of the porn trap for good do take their slips seriously.

They just don't beat themselves up endlessly because of them.

They learn from what happened and adjust their plan going forward.

A guy can have a bad night and still be a good man.

And a guy who believes that is ready to make a better choice when the next chance shows up.

Mine showed up the very next day under a table.

And yours is coming too.

Questions Guys Ask Me About This

Why do I binge after relapsing on porn?

The binge usually starts with what a guy tells himself right after the first slip. He decides he's already blown it, so the rest of the night, or the weekend, doesn't seem to count anymore. Add shame on top, and porn becomes the fastest way to stop feeling like garbage, which sets up the next round. Researchers call that pattern the abstinence violation effect.

Does one slip mean I'm back to square one?

Not on its own. One slip is one night. What usually sends a guy back to square one is the spiral after it: the bad weekend, week or month that starts with "I already blew it anyway." A slip he takes seriously, without deciding it says who he is, is something he can learn from.

Why do I feel so disgusting after watching porn?

Part of that feeling can be useful. It's a guy's sense that what he did doesn't match the man he wants to be, and that kind of guilt can push him to change. The trouble starts when it turns into "I'm disgusting" or "I'll never beat this." That's shame aimed at who he is, and shame tends to push a guy to hide and escape. And porn is one of the easiest escapes he has.

Can shame help me quit porn?

Usually not the way a guy hopes. Shame feels like it should work as a brake. But in the 2011 study above, more shame went with more of the compulsive behavior, not less. Guilt about what he did, without deciding he's a bad man, is the feeling that went with wanting to change and working on it.


Get the next one tomorrow.

These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.

Devin McDermott

Devin McDermott

I was hooked on porn for 13 years. I've been free for nearly six, and I've coached 170+ men through it since. No shame, no lectures.

My storyWork with me

Keep reading

Every post

Sources

  • The abstinence violation effect: Marlatt, G. A., & Gordon, J. R. (Eds.). (1985). Relapse Prevention: Maintenance Strategies in the Treatment of Addictive Behaviors. Guilford Press.
  • People who relapsed after a slip made more internal, stable and global attributions for it than people who got back on track: Curry, S., Marlatt, G. A., & Gordon, J. R. (1987). Abstinence violation effect: Validation of an attributional construct with smoking cessation. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 55(2), 145-149. doi:10.1037/0022-006X.55.2.145.
  • Guilt (about a behavior) tends to motivate repair, shame (about the self) tends to motivate hiding and escape: Tangney, J. P., Stuewig, J., & Mashek, D. J. (2007). Moral emotions and moral behavior. Annual Review of Psychology, 58, 345-372. doi:10.1146/annurev.psych.56.091103.070145.
  • In an online survey of 177 people seeking treatment for compulsive porn use, shame predicted more of the behavior, and guilt went with motivation to change and with change behaviors (a one-time survey, so it can't show cause): Gilliland, R., South, M., Carpenter, B. N., & Hardy, S. A. (2011). The roles of shame and guilt in hypersexual behavior. Sexual Addiction & Compulsivity, 18(1), 12-29. doi:10.1080/10720162.2011.551182.