Let Me Just Test It: Why a Guy on a Good Streak Goes Back to Porn
By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach
After a month clean, a guy starts wondering if he should test himself with porn. Why that test fails at step one, and what wanting to take it tells him.
A guy on a call once told me about the two sentences that would show up in his head right before he slipped.
He'd been working on quitting for about two years.
And at first, he was putting together streaks of 30 to 45 days.
But then the triggers started stacking up. Social media. Being bored in his room with nothing to do. And remembering the famous phrase "use it or lose it," he began questioning if he was perhaps actually dampening his sexual response through his abstinence.
(Which quitting porn definitely doesn't do, of course.)
And that's when the sentences would show up:
"Let me just check out this girl."
"I'll just test myself and prove I can control this."
"Let me just make sure the man downstairs still works..."
That second one especially sounds so reasonable.
Like a responsible guy checking his progress and seeing how strong he's gotten after a month clean.
And no doubt he is actually getting stronger.
Who's Running the Test
But think about how that test actually works:
The only way to take it is to take a look.
So the first step of the test is the exact thing he was trying not to do.
That he was feeling so proud of himself for not doing.
And once he's looking, the part of him running the "test" is the same part that wants to keep going.
That's The Animal, the part of his brain that chases dopamine, wearing the CEO's suit.
It knows "let me go watch something" would get shut down.
So it asks a question the CEO in him likes instead. Am I strong enough yet?
What the Test Is Really Telling Him
But nobody tests their control over something they've stopped wanting.
A happy ex-smoker would never take a puff of a cigarette just to prove to themselves that they can avoid smoking it.
So when the test shows up it's actually telling him something useful.
Part of him still wants it and it's found a respectable way to ask.
That's how a guy with a 45-day streak ends up starting over and over again... by accepting the deceptions The Animal is feeding to him.
And the question worth asking right then is what that part of him is still after.
Relapse Researchers Saw This Decades Ago
The psychologist Alan Marlatt and his colleagues studied how people who've quit drinking end up drinking again.
In their model, a relapse can start with small choices that don't look like they have anything to do with drinking.
The example they give is someone who's quit drinking and buys a bottle of liquor, "just in case guests stop by."
The bottle is for the guests. That's the story, anyway.
And then one bad night, it's already in the house.
They called these "apparently irrelevant decisions." Each one looks harmless when it's made. But a few of them in a row can walk someone right up to a drink.
"I'll just test myself" works the same way. To a guy a month in, it sounds like a check-in on his progress. But it walks him straight to the one place he was trying to stay away from.
The sentence itself has a name, too. In their 1993 book on substance abuse, Aaron Beck and his colleagues called sentences like it permission-giving beliefs: the reasons a person gives himself that make using feel justified.
The ones that get past him sound like progress, or curiosity, or responsibility.
Which is exactly why the idea of a test is so convincing to a guy who's been doing well.
What "Use It or Lose It" Leaves Out
The last sentence on that call, "Let me just make sure the man downstairs still works," grew out of that famous phrase.
A guy hears "use it or lose it" and starts to worry that staying away from porn is quietly hurting him.
And there is a real study that seems to back the phrase up. Researchers in Finland followed 989 men aged 55 to 75 for five years and published the results in 2008. The men who had sex less than once a week developed erection problems at about twice the rate of the men who had sex once a week.
But that study was about sex with a partner. It didn't measure porn or masturbation at all, so it says nothing about a guy who stops watching porn.
And for a lot of men, porn is the problem in the first place. At 21, I had a beautiful girl in my bed and I couldn't keep it up. I'd been watching porn almost every day since I was 13. After I quit, that healed.
So when that worry turns into a reason to "check," the timing is worth noticing. For the guy on that call, it showed up right before he slipped, along with the other two sentences.
Questions Guys Ask Me About This
Is it okay to look at porn to test if I'm over it?
It's a test a guy fails at the first step, because the only way to take it is to look. And wanting to take it is already a result. It means part of him still wants porn and has found a way to ask that sounds responsible.
Why do I want to test myself after a good streak?
Feeling strong makes the idea sound reasonable. After a month clean, "let me see how far I've come" sounds like a fair question. But usually it's the part of a guy that still wants porn, asking in a way the disciplined part of him will say yes to.
Will quitting porn weaken my erections?
Nothing in the "use it or lose it" study says it will. That study followed Finnish men aged 55 to 75 and looked only at sex with a partner. For a lot of guys, it goes the other way: porn is what made real-life sex harder, and the problem starts to ease once porn is gone. That's how it went for me.
How do I know if I'm really over porn?
You stop wanting to find out. When you're done with porn, the urge to "test" goes quiet along with the rest of it, and a good month stops being something you need to prove.
Get the next one tomorrow.
These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.
Keep reading
The Night After a Slip: Why One Bad Night Turns Into a Bad Month5 min read
Surviving Work Trips: Why Porn Comes Back When She's Away5 min read
His Bloodwork Came Back Normal, and He Still Felt Broken7 min read
Why 'Just Stop' Rarely Works on a Habit a Guy's Been Hiding for Years7 min read
What Kevin Gates Said About Porn and Semen Retention, and What the Studies Back Up8 min read
Why a Guy Who Wants to Stop Gooning Still Looks Up at 3 AM6 min read
Why a Guy Keeps Going Back to Porn Even After He's Decided to Stop8 min read
The Restaurant Test: Why a Guy Can Love Her and Still Drift Off at Dinner7 min read
Sources
- "Apparently irrelevant decisions," including the example of an abstinent drinker who buys a bottle "just in case guests stop by": Larimer, M. E., Palmer, R. S., & Marlatt, G. A. (1999). Relapse prevention: An overview of Marlatt's cognitive-behavioral model. Alcohol Research & Health, 23(2), 151-160. PMC6760427.
- Permission-giving beliefs in addiction: Beck, A. T., Wright, F. D., Newman, C. F., & Liese, B. S. (1993). Cognitive Therapy of Substance Abuse. Guilford Press.
- In 989 Finnish men aged 55 to 75, intercourse less than once a week went with about twice the five-year rate of erectile dysfunction compared with once a week (an observational study of partnered sex only; masturbation wasn't assessed): Koskimäki, J., et al. (2008). Regular intercourse protects against erectile dysfunction: Tampere Aging Male Urologic Study. The American Journal of Medicine, 121(7), 592-596. doi:10.1016/j.amjmed.2008.02.042.
- Porn use and erectile problems in young men, including clinical reports of men whose ED eased after they stopped: Park, B. Y., Wilson, G., Berger, J., et al. (2016). Is Internet pornography causing sexual dysfunctions? A review with clinical reports. Behavioral Sciences, 6(3), 17. PMC5039517.
- In 3,419 men aged 18 to 35, higher problematic porn use went with higher odds of ED (cross-sectional): Jacobs, T., Geysemans, B., Van Hal, G., et al. (2021). Associations between online pornography consumption and sexual dysfunction in young men. JMIR Public Health and Surveillance, 7(10), e32542. PMC8569536.