Devin McDermott
Work with me
Get the daily email Work with me
A man seen from behind in a small wooden rowboat on a lake at golden hour, bailing water over the side with a bucket while water trickles in through a crack in the hull behind him

20 Years of Fighting the Wrong Thing: What Porn Was Really Doing for Him

By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach

Blog4 minute read

He fought porn for over 20 years with willpower, accountability and blockers. What changed things was finally seeing the three jobs porn was doing for him.

I want to tell you about one of the 170+ men I've helped, who I'll call J.

He sent me a message once, a couple months after he quit. It started like this:

“I feel like a completely different person through our time of working together.”

That’s a big thing to say based on where he started.

Twenty Years of Trying Everything

J had been fighting porn for over 20 years.

And it's not like he'd been resting on his laurels.

In his words he’d been battling it endlessly “through failing willpower, accountability, and internet blockers”.

He felt like he'd tried everything.

And he just didn't know where to turn anymore.

Unfortunately, this is how willpower fails a lot of guys.

It holds for a while, until a bad day comes along, or a long week, and he gets pulled right back to where he started and is left wondering "what more do I need to do?? Will I ever beat this?"

Twenty years is a long time to keep losing the same fight.

Three Different Jobs

What changed things for J was finally seeing what porn had been doing for him the whole time.

He wrote that he’d been using it “to make me feel better when I’m down, reward myself for ‘deserving it,’ or to temporarily satisfy my lust.”

That’s three different jobs: something to lift him on a bad day, a prize after a hard one, and a quick way to quiet the urge.

Researchers Asked Thousands of People Why They Watch

In 2021 a team of researchers led by Beáta Bőthe set out to measure why people watch porn in the first place. Across three studies with more than 2,600 people they landed on eight reasons.

Some were about sex: pleasure, curiosity, fantasy, self-exploration and not being satisfied with their sex life. The other three had nothing to do with sex at all: easing stress, escaping boredom and pushing hard feelings out of the way.

Then they looked at which reasons went along with porn use that had turned into a problem. Stress, boredom and sexual pleasure all showed up. So did fantasy and using porn to push feelings away, and those two showed up even though neither one tracked with how often people watched.

So whether porn becomes a problem is tied to what it's doing for a guy.

J's "feel better when I'm down" sits right next to what those researchers called stress reduction and emotional distraction. His "temporarily satisfy my lust" is the sexual side. And "deserving it" is a job of its own: a prize a guy hands himself when he feels he's earned something.

Why the Pull Kept Coming Back

Willpower, accountability and blockers can all help of course.

But they all aim at the porn itself, and none of them touches the jobs it's doing.

The gaps it's filling. The something that's missing.

So the pull kept coming back because the jobs were still open. Bad days still needed that numbing agent. The hard week still wanted its reward.

When There's Nothing Left to Fight

When you really solve this problem, you stop needing accountability and blockers to hold you back. Because when you've done the right work and don't need or want porn at all anymore... there’s nothing left to fight.

Which leaves one question that matters:

How do you get to a point where you genuinely don't need or want it anymore and happily leave it behind?

J got there, and he told me how in that same message:

“By not only abstaining from acting on these cravings but by fulfilling those needs with a more positive life and discipline I have finally been able to see how much more appealing a life of freedom from this addiction truly is.”

Those needs are the three jobs from earlier. Once he was meeting them with a better life, porn had no job left to do.

Here’s how the rest of his message went:

“Quitting porn and working with you to change my lifestyle has led to me eating healthier... getting in shape, fixing my marriage, cutting out time wasting activities, getting more productive... I am more present in conversations, can look people in the eye again...”

Not bad for a guy who spent 20 years losing the same fight.

Questions Guys Ask Me About This

Is it too late to quit porn after 20 years?

Not from what I've seen. J had been fighting it for over 20 years when things finally changed for him. I was hooked for about 13 years myself, and I quit nearly 6 years ago. After that many years it can feel permanent. That's also a long time for porn to pick up jobs in a guy's life, and those jobs are where to look.

Why do I watch porn when I'm stressed or down?

Because for a few minutes it works. Porn is one of the fastest ways a guy knows to stop feeling something. In the 2021 study above, stress and pushing feelings away were both among the reasons tied to problem use. But the feeling is still there afterward, usually with shame piled on top of it.

Why do I feel like I deserve porn after a hard day?

Because porn has taken on the job of a prize. After a hard day or a long week a guy feels like he's earned something, and porn is the quickest reward on hand. That's the job J named when he wrote about rewarding himself for "deserving it." And a good stretch can set it off too.

Do blockers and accountability help you quit porn?

They can help. A blocker makes porn harder to reach and an accountability partner makes it harder to hide. But both aim at the porn itself, and neither one touches the jobs porn is doing for a guy, so the bad day still needs something. Once those jobs get filled another way you don't need either one to hold you back. You can keep some guardrails in place as you move on with your life. They just aren't the only thing standing between you and porn anymore.


Get the next one tomorrow.

These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.

Devin McDermott

Devin McDermott

I was hooked on porn for 13 years. I've been free for nearly six, and I've coached 170+ men through it since. No shame, no lectures.

My storyWork with me

Keep reading

Every post

Sources

  • The three studies (772, 792 and 1,082 participants), the eight motivations (sexual pleasure, sexual curiosity, emotional distraction or suppression, stress reduction, fantasy, boredom avoidance, lack of sexual satisfaction and self-exploration), the weak-to-moderate positive links with problematic pornography use (stress reduction, emotional distraction or suppression, boredom avoidance, fantasy and sexual pleasure) and with frequency of use (only sexual pleasure, boredom avoidance and stress reduction): Bőthe, B., Tóth-Király, I., Bella, N., Potenza, M. N., Demetrovics, Z., & Orosz, G. (2021). Why do people watch pornography? The motivational basis of pornography use. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 35(2), 172-186. https://doi.org/10.1037/adb0000603.