Devin McDermott
Work with me
Get the daily email Work with me
A stone shrine niche in warm afternoon light, with a clean outline in the dust where a lamp used to stand and a plain clay lamp beside it

Twenty Minutes Doesn't Sound Like Much: The Real Price of Porn

By Devin McDermott, porn recovery coach

Blog5 minute read

A guy counts porn in minutes, so it never seems like much. A thief stole Epictetus's lamp 1,900 years ago, and the price he paid shows what the minutes hide.

About 1,900 years ago, it's said that the Greek philosopher Epictetus kept an iron lamp next to the shrine in his house.

Until one day he heard a noise at the door, and when he hurried down...

The lamp was gone.

Someone had stolen it.

You'd expect a guy to be mad about that.

But Epictetus wrote that the thief got his lamp because the thief was more alert than he was.

Fair enough.

What the Thief Really Paid

Then he wrote something I really love.

The thief, he said, also paid a price for that lamp:

"In exchange for it he consented to become a thief: in exchange for it, to become faithless."

So the thief walked away with a lamp.

But he paid for it with something worth a lot more than a lamp.

Meanwhile Epictetus just figured his next lamp would be a clay one.

How a Guy Prices Porn

Incidentally, a lot of guys price porn the way that thief priced the lamp.

They count it in minutes.

Twenty minutes. An hour. A late night.

And by that math it doesn't seem like very much, right?

But the true cost is just less obvious. He's paying with a lot more than minutes.

With the morning he'd planned. With the energy he was going to bring to the gym, or to work, or to her. With his presence, self-respect, and confidence.

With a little dishonesty when she asks what's wrong and he says "nothing."

And a little trust in himself every time he breaks a promise he made to nobody but him.

That's why it can feel like such a bad deal afterward, even when nobody ever finds out.

He knows deep down what he paid.

Once a guy starts counting what he trades for it instead of just the minutes, the math begins looking completely different.

And the math of quitting starts to look a lot more promising, too.

Why the Minutes Are the Only Part He Sees

There's a reason the minutes are the only number that shows up.

A 2009 study by researchers at Yale and two other universities looked at how people decide whether to buy something. One of the experiments asked people if they'd buy a DVD for about $15.

For some of them the choice not to buy was described plainly. For others it was described as "keeping the money for other purchases."

That small reminder cut the number of people who wanted the DVD by about 20 percent.

Nobody needed to be told that $15 could buy other things. They just weren't thinking about it until somebody put it in front of them. The researchers called that opportunity cost neglect.

Their study was about money. But I think the same blind spot shows up with porn.

The minutes are right there on the clock. But the morning he planned, the honesty and the trust in himself don't show up anywhere unless he goes looking for them. So he goes by the one number he can see, and it's always the small one.

What Happened to the Clay Lamp

The clay lamp has a story of its own.

Decades later the satirist Lucian made fun of a man who had paid 3,000 drachmas for Epictetus's clay lamp. That was a huge price. Lucian figured the buyer hoped that reading by it would bring Epictetus's wisdom to him in his dreams.

So the thief paid with his character to get an iron lamp. Epictetus wouldn't pay that price and kept his. And the clay lamp he settled for ended up worth a fortune because of the man who owned it.

Quitting can feel a bit like settling for clay. But a guy who stops paying with his honesty and his word to himself gets to keep them. And keeping them is the same thing that made Epictetus's lamp worth 3,000 drachmas.

Questions Guys Ask Me About This

Is watching porn a waste of time?

Time is the smallest part of what it costs. A guy can shrug off twenty minutes. But it's harder to see what goes with them: the plans he'd made for the morning, his energy at work, and a little of his trust in himself each time he goes back on his word. I wrote more about what porn costs a guy who looks fine from the outside.

Is it bad to watch porn if it's only for a few minutes?

By the clock a few minutes looks like nothing, and that's the trap. The clock only measures one thing. A better measure is what the rest of his day looked like afterward and whether he kept the promise he made himself.

Why do I feel so bad after watching porn, even when nobody knows?

Because part of a guy keeps counting what it really cost, even when the clock says it was only a few minutes. Nobody has to find out for him to know he broke his word to himself. That bad-deal feeling afterward is him doing the math.

Why does porn feel worth it in the moment but not afterward?

In the moment the only price he can see is a few minutes, and a few minutes sounds cheap. The rest of the bill comes later. It might be a night at home where he's in the room but not really with her, or an early start he sleeps right through. And it's there again the next time he promises himself he's done and can't quite trust it.

What did Epictetus say about his stolen lamp?

He said the thief was better at staying awake than he was, so the thief got the lamp. Then he said the thief paid a price of his own. To get it the thief agreed to become a thief and to give up his good faith. Epictetus's own plan was to use a clay lamp next time.

Is quitting porn actually worth it?

It's one of the best trades a guy can make. He gives up a few minutes that never felt like much. And he stops paying with his honesty, his energy and his word to himself, so he gets to keep all three. There's more Epictetus in why a man who answers to nobody still can't leave porn alone.


Get the next one tomorrow.

These posts start as my daily email. One short email a day on why the habit runs and how to take it apart. 3,965+ men read it.

Devin McDermott

Devin McDermott

I was hooked on porn for 13 years. I've been free for nearly six, and I've coached 170+ men through it since. No shame, no lectures.

My storyWork with me

Keep reading

Every post

Sources

  • The stolen iron lamp beside Epictetus's household shrine and the thief who was "superior to me" in wakefulness: Epictetus, Discourses 1.18 and 1.29 (George Long translation), Perseus Digital Library.
  • "In exchange for it he consented to become a thief: in exchange for it, to become faithless" and the earthenware lamp he planned to use next: The Golden Sayings of Epictetus, section XIII, translated by Hastings Crossley. Project Gutenberg.
  • The DVD experiment (interest in buying a $15 DVD fell by 20 percent when not buying was described as "keeping the money for other purchases") and the term opportunity cost neglect: Frederick, S., Novemsky, N., Wang, J., Dhar, R., & Nowlis, S. (2009). Opportunity cost neglect. Journal of Consumer Research, 36(4), 553-561. Yale School of Management summary.
  • The man who paid 3,000 drachmas for Epictetus's earthenware lamp, hoping its wisdom would come to him in his dreams: Lucian, The Ignorant Book-Collector (Adversus indoctum), 13, translated by A. M. Harmon (Loeb, 1921). Perseus Digital Library.